Monday, October 2, 2023
HomeAAD 2023Practicing Ethical Medicine 'A Requirement,' Not a Luxury, Expert Says

Practicing Ethical Medicine ‘A Requirement,’ Not a Luxury, Expert Says

NEW ORLEANS – Demonstrated adherence to professional and ethical principles is one of the six core competencies for the dermatology residency curriculum set by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education, but results from a national survey of dermatology residency program directors suggest that ethics training is not a priority.

Of the 139 dermatology residency program or associate program directors surveyed in 2022, only 43% responded. Of these, 55% said that their program had no ethics curriculum. Among programs with an ethics curriculum, 75% were implemented in the past 10 years, and the most common settings for teaching ethics were formal didactics (32%) and ad hoc during clinical encounters (28%). Reported barriers to implementing and/or maintaining an ethics curriculum included a lack of time (30%), lack of faculty with expertise (24%), and lack of useful resources (20%).

“Clearly, medical ethics is needed more to be part of our dermatology residency curriculum,” one of the study authors, Jane M. Grant-Kels, MD, professor of dermatology, pathology, and pediatrics, and founding chair of dermatology at the University of Connecticut, Farmington, said during a plenary lecture at the annual meeting of the American Academy of Dermatology. “Why? Because even though we’re physicians, and some of us have big egos, we are just human beings. We have all the faults and frailties of other humans. What we do as doctors often has unintended consequences that impact patients and society at large.”

Dr. Jane M. Grant-Kels

Dr. Grant-Kels, one of the editors of the textbook “Dermatoethics“, said that, while she does not believe that physicians are intentionally unethical, “we stumble into bad behavior because we fool ourselves. We think that we are ethical. We think our colleagues are ethical, and we don’t view them with a clear, transparent eye. This is referred to as ethical fading or bounded ethicality.”

Similar to religion and good behavior, one can’t really teach someone to be ethical, she continued. “But you can teach people to think about ethics and to recognize an ethical dilemma when they’re in one,” she said. “Most articles that are available [pertain to] whether ethics can be taught or not, but there are very few resources available on how to actually teach ethics.”

That, she added, has been her goal for the last 2 decades: “How do I teach ethics without sounding like I’m more ethical than anybody else, and how do I make it relevant and fun? It’s a difficult challenge.”

Pillars of medical ethics

Dr. Grant-Kels defined ethics as a way of determining how individuals ought to act based on concepts of right and wrong. An ethical dilemma is when an individual faces two competing possibilities: either both justifiable or both unjustifiable, and you have to make a decision. The four pillars of medical ethics, she noted, are beneficence (the notion that the patient’s best interests come first); nonmaleficence (do no intentional harm); autonomy (the patient’s right to refuse or choose a treatment); and justice (fairness in how health care is distributed).

“Medical ethics are the moral principles by which physicians should conduct themselves,” she said. “There is normative ethics, which involves decisions about which moral norms or ethical arguments should we accept and why; and applied ethics, or applications of these norms to specific problems or cases. No ethics is better than bad ethics, and we can see that even in today’s world. The lack of ethics, or poor ethics, or the wrong ethics has terrible consequences.”

Ethics instruction

Dr. Grant-Kels provided a “top 10 list” of tips for incorporating ethics instruction into dermatology residency programs and clinical practices:

  • Make room for ethics in your curriculum. “It’s not science, and it needs to be discussed and developed with faculty and residents,” she said.

  • Focus on real situations that residents will experience. Discuss what you should do, what you might have done, and why.

  • Share stories and be truthful. Include other faculty members, “because you need different perspectives,” she said.

  • Go beyond what is right and wrong, and the rationale. “You have to talk about the impact, because decisions you make have unintended consequences for individual patients and for patient care in general,” Dr. Grant-Kels said.

  • Practice, practice, practice. Make time for discussions involving ethics, “because it takes a lot of education to be able to identify ethical issues and process them,” she said. “The truth is, we can rationalize almost anything and convince ourselves that we made the right choice. That’s why we need to continue to practice good ethics.”

  • Challenge the residents. “Decisions are not always straightforward,” she said. “Pressures push us and we start to justify small decisions and then bigger decisions. This is a very gray zone. What’s ethical for one person may not be ethical to another.”

  • Encourage residents and colleagues to ask the right questions and give them confidence to make the right decisions. “We have to work in an environment of ethics,” Dr. Grant-Kels said. “Many of us are role models, and we are not always behaving the way we should be. As role models, we need to be aware of that.”

  • Expose residents to a variety of issues. Ethics vary depending on the situation, the people involved, and the information presented.

  • Ethics cannot just come up in an ethics class. “We need to foster a culture of ethics,” she said. “If things go wrong and unethical behavior is noted, it needs to be brought to the floor and discussed.”

  • Discuss the misguided pursuit of happiness and ethical decision-making. In the opinion of Dr. Grant-Kels, people can behave badly when they’re pursuing something like a career advancement, a new house, or an expensive object like a car or a boat. “They think that if they get that job or get that promotion or if they buy that big house or they buy that sports car, they’re going to be really happy,” she said.

“That’s called impact bias, which causes focalism, where you focus on that one thing, like ‘I’m going to make a lot of money’ or ‘I’m going to buy that big house on the mountain.’ The truth is, buying that car doesn’t make you happy. Buying that big house doesn’t make you happy. We need to combat focalism with professionalism, which means conducting oneself with responsibility, integrity, accountability, and excellence. Practicing ethical medicine is not a luxury; it’s a requirement. We should all try for aspirational ethics.”

Dr. Grant-Kels reported having no relevant financial disclosures.

This article originally appeared on, part of the Medscape Professional Network.

- Advertisment -

Most Popular